Skip to main content

Review: The Girl on the Train


(Contains Spoilers)
Author - Paula Hawkins
Genre - Thriller
No. of Pages - 395(US)/ 320(UK)
Year of Publication - 2015
Rating - ❤️❤️❤️
This book has won 2015 Goodreads Choice award in best mystery and thriller category and it was at No. 1 among The New York Times Fiction bestsellers of 2015. My hopes were high, but it did not match my expectations. When you read a thriller, you expect something out of everything. Like each word seems like a clue and you try to solve the mystery on your own by cracking those clues. I didn't get any major clues while reading this book. And it was quite exhausting. 

The readers who have already read this book would relate more to my review.

Rachel is a 32 years old alcoholic, divorced from her husband Tom, who is now married to Anna, the 'mistress'. Another couple lives a few houses away from Tom and Anna's house(where Tom and Rachel lived once), their names are Scott and Megan.

First, the protagonist Rachel Watson is an alcoholic and trying to cope with the loss of her marriage, her divorce. She goes to and fro on the same train without any aim(she lost her job months ago), to London and roams around. Who does that? I mean it's OK that she is depressed and all that stuff and it's also OK to go on meaningless train journeys once in a while but for months? It's too much. 

Second, Rachel is obsessed. She watches a couple from the train living in house number fifteen, a few houses away from where she lived with her husband. And she is so obsessed that she even names them as Jess and Jason and imagines what there life must be like. 
P.S. - Jess and Jason are actually, Scott and Megan.

Third, I had many unanswered questions.

  1. The blue cloth Rachel saw, lying on the tracks, twice, while her journey on the train. What was that about? I thought throughout the book that it had something to do with the mystery but nothing came out.
  2. The deja vu Rachel had of Anna wearing a blue dress with black belt going into the car or running away from her. What was that all about? I found no explanations.
  3. I know Megan had an affair with Kamal, her therapist. That was quite clear. But later, we find out that she had an affair with Tom too. That was quite disgusting and confusing at the same time. 
Fourth, women are shown as a total fool. You will understand this point when you read the book. I won't spoil the mystery completely. 

Fifth, I knew that Scott or Kamal were not guilty, from the beginning. I just knew. And the kind of climax I was expecting, it wasn't up to that mark. I wanted more clarity and answers.

I won't say that I disliked this book but I didn't love it. I wanted to love it. It is quite popular and I had longed to read it for a while. Considering the amount of curiosity I had, I was disappointed. I don't know whether it's just me with lots of questions and confusions or there are people who can relate to me but this is what I felt. I'll certainly recommend this book to the readers who love reading thrillers because if I didn't love it, doesn't mean you won't love it.  

Review by Bhumika Singh (Blog Author)

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Review: The Notebook

Author - Nicholas Sparks Genre - Romance No. of Pages - 224 Year of Publication - 1996 Rating - ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ 'Noah and Allie'. I consider them the modern Romeo and Juliet. This was my first Sparks' novel and I literally fell in love with his writing after reading it. Characters, setup, plot, expression, I give this novel ten on ten for everything. I don't like reading ebooks personally but I had heard so much about this book that I couldn't wait to buy a paperback and downloaded the ebook. This book is a pure romantic fiction but it is not boring at all. The author has portrayed the characters of Noah and Allie so beautifully that you will certainly fall in love with them. The book opens with an old man giving his introduction while he heads towards a room. A room where he has been going for three years just to narrate the same story to a woman suffering from Alzheimer . The story he reads from his notebook is about Noah and Allie.  They meet each other whe...

Review: Safe Haven

Author - Nicholas Sparks Genre - Romance No. of Pages - 432 Year of Publication - 2011 Rating - ❤️❤️❤️ After reading The Notebook , I had high expectations from any other Sparks' book. I wouldn't say that I didn't like this book. All in all it was an okay read. I liked Erin's character a lot. She is portrayed as an independent and brave woman and yes, intelligent too. Alex is a decent character who showcases the idealistic image of a single father who loves and cares for his children more than anything else in the world. And lastly, Kevin, who would like him when he is the self proclaimed villain? I guess no one. Erin moves to Southport, North Carolina after fleeing from her husband, Kevin's house. Erin fell in love with Kevin and they got married but just after a few years of marriage, Erin discovered how obsessed he is with himself and how he wants total control over her moves and her life.  She felt suffocated in his house. She wasn't even al...

Review: Before I Go To Sleep

(Contains Spoilers) Author - SJ Watson Genre - Thriller No. of Pages - 368 Year of Publication - 2011 Rating - ❤️❤️❤️(3.5) I admit, this book had me guessing till the end. And the ending wasn't something that I saw coming.  I found this book far more thrilling than 'The Girl On The Train' which was somehow predictable for me. In the beginning, I didn't have even a speck of hint or clue about the climax. That's the thing that kept me glued to this book and I read it by spending my one whole day. I won't say it was a "proper page turner". I had some difficulty in reading the starting one-third part of it because it wasn't much appealing and things were repetitive. But it took a pace after around half of it was read. And the climax was excellent. The book revolves around a woman named Christine Lucas who is suffering from amnesia. She is living from moment to moment without having any idea about her past or future. Her case of amnesia is ...

Followers